Skip to main content

7 Reasons to Keep Your Mouth Shut


Many years ago during my short stint at a PR firm, we flew to a client to make a presentation. Minutes after we arrived, a senior executive walked up to us and told us that our key contact at the company passed away last night. To that, my boss impulsively snapped, “Well, didn’t you do your succession planning? We flew up here and expect to present to someone.” Trying not to look at the utterly stupefied face of the poor guy, I could only hear ear-numbing silence following that short retort from my boss. I vaguely remember a bird or two chirping at a distance too.
Well, I do admire all facets of verbal communication skills and am highly respectful of everyone who takes eloquence and articulation to the next level. But more often than not, it is the failure to appreciate when to keep quiet that lands most people in trouble. For discerning employers, a finely honed sense of when not to talk is a highly sought-after communication skill that is hard to come by. As someone so aptly put it:
"The ability to speak several languages is an asset, but the ability to keep your mouth shut in any language is priceless."
From my humbling experience of the past many years, here’s a list of 7 reasons why (and when) to keep your mouth shut:

1. Listen, observe and learn

The greatest business lessons are learnt when you are not talking, but listening. It is a proven fact that if you are talking or thinking of what to say when the other person finishes the sentence, you are not listening to what is being said. This is because listening is not hearing. It is a cognitive exercise that requires concentration to process the knowledge being imparted. How well you can interpret that knowledge depends largely on your level of concentration and impartial attention. I like how Cheryl Conner put it:
"There is a power in listening to others without interruption in order to fully understand what they are saying—to fully understand what they are not saying—and to ensure that they know they are heard."

2. Do not speak only to criticize

If you feel the urge to speak up only to sneer at someone’s failure or shortcoming with no constructive intent to it, it is better to keep quiet. This is not to say that you should never criticize someone within the accepted norms of social discourse. It only means that in business meetings, criticizing an individual with an intent to belittle him or her is not a good idea simply because the negative intent tends to become evident the more you speak. This applies to shifting the blame to an adversary or to someone you have to settle a score with.
"Abilities wither under fault-finding, blossom under encouragement." Donald A. Laird
If you are a born mentor and coach who can’t refrain from pointing out areas of improvement, make sure you do that in one-on-one meetings only after building a strong rapport with the individual. If you are truly concerned about the person’s contribution to the organization, the focus should be on offering solutions rather than on rubbing it in his face. 

3. Do not speak when angry

Like listening, speaking is a cognitive process. The MIT Encyclopedia of the Cognitive Sciences says, "it seems plausible to maintain that universal tendencies in language are grounded in the way we are; this must be so for speaking is a cognitive capacity, that capacity in virtue of which we say that we know our native language."
Performance of a cognitive skill hinges on the capacity of the brain to function normally. The data coming into our brain from the world around us passes through the amygdala where the decision is made whether to send the data to the limbic area or frontal lobe of the cerebral cortex. The latter assesses consequences of our actions and is likely what's keeping you from hurling a vase across the room. If the incoming data triggers enough of an emotional charge, amygdala sends the data to the limbic system causing the person to react without much regard for the consequences.
"Speak when you are angry - and you'll make the best speech you'll ever regret." Lawrence J. Peter
Simply put, we are not in our right mind when we are angry. Regardless of whether your anger is justified or not, it is highly advisable to wait for the storm to pass before you see the bright sun of your cognition shining in your head again. Speaking your mind before the frontal lobe takes over is akin to driving when drunk. All you'll end up with is truckload of regret and a few broken hearts. Not to mention, I have seen people losing their jobs only because they spoke when they should have kept quiet.

4. Do not speak to spread rumors

Rumors are short-lived. They eventually get discovered as lies and when that happens, all those we took part in spreading the false news move a step closer to losing their credibility. Blabbermouths are always looked down upon in a professional work environment even when they really want to believe what they are saying is true.
"Doubting everything is a sign of wisdom; speaking your doubts is mere stupidity."
By the same token, saying something while at the same time expressing your doubt about it harms your professional integrity. It is better not to speak if you are unsure whether what you are going to say is the truth and you did not have a chance to confirm the piece of information. Rather than saying "I think the survey results were largely positive and we can start developing the marketing campaign" you can simply take away the question and confirm the survey results in the next meeting.

5. Do not speak to state the obvious

In business meetings, stating the obvious is a suicidal faux-pas that went out of style centuries ago. It only serves to demonstrate that you are an uber-naive person going through an intellectual challenge keeping pace with the discussion.
Same goes for reading your PowerPoint slides verbatim. Irrespective of how verbose the slides are, present the context of the phrase and what meaning you want to convey rather than reading out the exact phrase. If you do not have anything to say about the why and how of the text written on the slides, what is the point of making the presentation in the first place? Consider sending the file as an attachment to save time and effort.
There is an exception to this. If you are stating the obvious only to build the premise for the point you are about to make, go for it by all means.

6. Conserve energy for action

Speaking is an energy-consuming exercise, but when it comes to expressing your intentions too early, speaking becomes an energy-depleting exercise. Once you've told people of your intentions, it gives you a "premature sense of completeness."
You have identity triggers in your brain that contribute to your self-image every time an event occurs. Since both actions and speech activate your identity triggers to shape your self-image one bit at a time, talking satisfies the brain enough to neglect the pursuit of action triggers. It is a common observation that announcing your intentions ahead of time satisfies your need to create a particular self-image just enough to lessen the motivation needed to achieve it.
NYU psychology professor Peter Gollwitzer has been studying this since his book "Symbolic Self-Completion" published in 1982. Recently published results reveal that people who keep their intentions private are more likely to achieve them than those who made them public and were acknowledged by others. JosemarĂ­a Escrivá wrote in his 1934 book, The Way:
"The fruitfulness of silence! All the energy I see you waste with those repeated indiscretions is energy taken from the effectiveness of your work. Be discreet."

7. Build power through silence

People with high self-esteem measure up the meaningfulness of a conversation against their self-value before jumping in. I have never seen an accomplished senior executive passing on a lame joke he heard in the elevator. In business meetings, each time you choose not to contribute to a meaningless discourse, it subliminally creates a perception in the minds of others that your contribution to a discussion is truly valuable and they will be eager to hear what you have to say the next time you speak.
Practising it consistently strengthens this perception and builds your intellectual self-worth. Avoiding meaningless talk in business meetings creates respect from colleagues. Of course overdoing it would make you look rude and aloof. So it is important to have a reasonable threshold of what constitutes meaningfulness.
Photo Credit: Peter Dutton

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Back to the Basics of Self Empowerment - Victim or Creator?

A young boy I was mentoring years ago as part of a program run by  The Citizens Foundation  in Pakistan blurted in middle of a group pep talk, "You don't understand sir, the whole world is against me; the teacher never gives me the marks that other students get for the same work." Being a mentor, I was a bit taken aback by that downbeat remark but I realized that I had to be sensitive to how strong emotions from other students might come into play. Before I even had a chance to wrap my head around the possible nuances of the comment, another boy cut in "But sir, he does not even try." Rewind one week to the orientation session; we all gathered in a small room already filled with a bunch of passionate boys and girls all wanting to make a real difference in the lives of less privileged students living on the outskirts of Karachi. An equally enthusiastic speaker adorned in crisp white shalwar kameez spoke about the Victim-Creator model of thinking. I was fas...

2014 Internationally Educated Professionals (IEP) Conference, Toronto

I spoke as part of the "Sales, Marketing and Communications" sector hub in the 11th Internationally Educated Professionals (IEP) Conference at the Metro Toronto Convention Centre in Toronto on Friday, April 11, 2014, attended by over 800 delegates. Please refer to the conference report for details. The focus of the IEP Conference is to bring IEPs from the five diverse sectors together with stakeholders to get career advice, discuss labour market information, and provide an orientation to Canadian job search practices and workplace culture. Conference stakeholders include: government, business professionals, educators, professional associations, regulatory, accreditation and credentialing bodies, and community-based organizations. The theme of this year’s IEP Conference was innovation, collaboration and cultural intelligence, building on the new IEP Conference format introduced last year. As always, networking is one of the pillars of the conference and the need f...

CIBC Awarded 2014 Employer of Distinction Award by ACCES Employment

I had the distinct honour of presenting the "2014 Employer of Distinction Award" to CIBC on behalf of the management and board of directors of ACCES Employment in ACCES’ 28 th Annual General Meeting on Tuesday, Sep 30, 2014. The event was attended by Hon. Michael Chan, Minister of Immigration, Citizenship and International Trade for the province of Ontario as the guest of honour, senior executives and board members of ACCES, as well as by members of the sponsoring organizations, prominent government institutions and the community at large. ACCES is a non-profit agency supported by the United Way. ACCES is a leader in connecting employers with qualified job seekers from diverse backgrounds who are primarily newcomers to Canada.  CIBC received this award for over 50 ACCES-sourced hirings through events such as ACCES Speed Networking and occupation specific programs like the Financial Services Connections Program. ACCES is an excellent example of an organizat...